70% of the out of writing like network text count plagiarism
- Details
- Category: Ningbo News
- Published: Friday, 06 July 2012 10:01
source 2012-7-6 9:17:19 Southeast Business
July 3, Foshan City, the test results would be released, the city Department of Education Department of specially selected from this year, 10 out of writing and published three excellent Pham Van. Pham Van released soon after a sharp-eyed netizens pointed out that the composition of which one out of even even the picture 2 in 2009 in Changsha, Hunan test out of a high degree of similar composition. "Writing is plagiarism?" Caused by the hot friends.
Day before yesterday, the person in charge of Foshan City Department of Education Department after a meeting to discuss re-interpretation of the article on the subject, and original content, finds that it is not plagiarism, it's still rated out.
Foshan this year out of writing
Fragment of conjugal love. "
Leaned over, bent over, his mother began to tie their shoes for his father, slender but not white hands quickly shuttle between the laces. Micro sip of mother lips, a wisp of long hair playfully down from the ears, her eyes focused, as if to knit beloved silk. Suddenly a light breeze blowing, the air maneuver with a hint of camphor taste, I felt a suddenly a move, as if what emerged.
Weekdays, always dignified father at this time, micro-head down, like a child makes a mistake, the afternoon sun swept over his face shone a light and shadow flicker circle cast in the side of the face, his eyes with a deep micro-Yang , as if across the Millennium constant through the air was dense with sunlight and dust, softly gazing at mother, standing face to face moment, with no written language, only Canruo fry the smile.
2009 in Changsha, Hunan
In the test out of composition
"In spring" fragments
Leaned over, bent over. The mother began to tie their shoes for the father. Mother's long hair supple hanging from Lianpang mouth micro-sip, draw a gentle arc, she is slim but not white fingers back and forth in his father shoelaces. Spring breezes beside the trees, the air pervaded the atmosphere of a touch of grass. Father head down, like a child making mistakes, soft eyes like a pool of deep water of the lake, as if separated for thousands of years, through the constancy of the sun and dust in the air, looking at the mother, their eyes staggered moment laugh no sound, no language, only Canruo the smiling faces of spring. I foolishly leaned against the door, but can not help but smile, smiling for the little things, for this wonderful moment.
Online article
"Moments" clips
Leaned over, bent over. The mother began to tie their shoes for the father! Summer breezes camphor green trees, breathtaking gossamer a touch of fragrant chrysanthemum tea.
Mother's long hair hanging in Lianpang supple mouth micro-sip, draw a gentle arc. Slim but not white finger in his father's shoelaces shuttle reply. Like a layer of tulle, the summer sun, devoid of a layer of light and shadow play on the side faces of the father's circle.
Father, head down, like a child making mistakes. Soft eyes like a pool of deep water of the lake, as if separated by thousands of years, constancy through the mixing of the air by the sun and Bliss, looking at the mother. Eyes staggered moment, laugh, no sound, no language, only smile Canruo fry.
Users: 70% of the online article similar
"Out in the essay" conjugal love "actually very similar to the article entitled" moments "with the network a work of plagiarism is rated out was to praise some, is simply ironic." Friends @ wicky1988 first in the microblogging broke the news, and soon attracted the concern of many users.
Reporters the day before yesterday to contact _AT_ wicky1988, he claimed to be a junior high school language teacher in Guangdong Shunde, accidentally discovered in the examination in which one out of writing an article he had seen of deja vu, search under very similar to the "moment" of this article .
"If you compare the two essays, you will find at least 70% of places are similar." The friends said that in accordance with the experience of the language composition score, "This has not borrowed, writing structure and individual statements imitate can be said to learn from him regardless of subject matter or statements are highly similar, but did not go beyond the original language. "The teachers believe that if it is based on the article should belong to the plagiarism.
The reporter then search the Internet for similar part even in the many articles have appeared in the article. Networks Bo Wen wonderful moment, "The World of (high school students) version of" 2008 the first 04 mid-term of "that song in the summer," 2009 Hunan Changsha in the test out of composition of two "in spring but also students", these articles have a "mother to help his father tie his shoe fiddle with hair and other details.
Discussion: out of composition operator is not plagiarism
Out composition of suspected plagiarism? Microblogging and forum, the matter caused some "war of words". Some users believe that, Although the details of the article words as well as conception and style have similarities, but not identical. "Test composition can not imitate it? Not be applied mechanically, references and even some of the material Pham Van for their own use can not be."
"If some of the same no problem, but the two articles too much." Parent comments that such a composition, even if then outstanding, and should not be named out of writing. "Out of writing will serve as a model, if the candidates moved essay could get out of the future which children write original composition, all back to Pham Van got."
Department to respond
Articles play not be deemed as plagiarism
The day before yesterday, the reporter linked to the Foshan Municipal Bureau of Education Department deputy director of the Tang Eng Zuan, he said, strict invigilation process, candidates can not entrained, so the site plagiarism.
"After the study, to see a few Pham Van indeed similar details, such as the laces of his father's, mother's hair, but the subject of several articles, in life it is indeed possible to encounter such a plot." Tang Eng Zan said, do not deny that the students may read the article, with some of the details, but according to their own language, re-interpretation of the theme.
Tang Eng Zuan also believe that after the deliberations of several teachers, the Foshan candidates written composition really than previous article.
Junior high school Pham Van back, but the mastery, and can not be applied mechanically, and must be innovative. Exam using some clips of people articles, this can not and university plagiarism par for junior high school students, the structure of the articles of others learn. "Tang Eng Zuan. As can be seen from the composition of the candidates in the last three paragraphs of original and re-interpretation of the subject. City Board of Education finds that the article is copied, still out of writing.
Is not part of plagiarism? Reporter failed to inform the background of the Foshanyizhong Language Leader Lee Cunren Event under the premise, its objective to two articles were reviews. "This article seems to have traces of plagiarism, but his creation." Li Cunren said, the student must have seen or experienced such a scene, but remember, it could use in the examination room, he also had to create, such as inscriptions warmth in the air are not very distant, as if nostalgia is no longer winter, that was blown over the summer ... the back of my hand turn off the sound, just wanders in the room singing suddenly dissipated. "Therefore, can not easily determine the "copy".
For many years served as the Guangdong College Entrance Examination marking composition is responsible for China Normal University professor Chen Miaoyun to determine plagiarism, we must provide the original to be copied, and at least similarity to more than 80%, if the candidates to read a story or a certain material, not blindly memorizing down the re-expression in their own language, but after the reconstruction, but also consistent with the essay topic is generally not judged to be copied.
Related News
Jiangsu a college entrance essay
Suspected of plagiarism
Examination Yuan is under investigation
Recently, Jiangsu Province exposed a college entrance examination score writing and writer Wang Kailing article is almost exactly the same, suspected of plagiarism. Examination Yuan in Jiangsu Province, said to have been aware of the matter is under investigation, to be informed of the results through expert certification before.
Users
Writing and the writer works exactly the same
Jiangsu newspaper each year will get a high score, good college entrance essay published in the newspaper, and add reviews. Jiangsu college entrance essay topic this year is "fear and love", a candidates bulk culture, language, points to the countryman simple nature of love, sorrow and countryman of disappearing very relevant this year's college entrance essay topic. The candidate's writing has also been published in the newspaper, but users found the article writer Wang Kailing article entitled "countryman where a high degree of similarity.
The friends said the candidate the beginning of the article, "I humbly believe, there are two types of human taste: a taste of vegetation, a Hunxing taste" and the article of Wang Kailing error is only one word, the original author wrote that "private thought". The article behind the language is almost the same: "Age can be divided into two: the rural character and urban character of the village's rich flavor, vegetation; city years, Hunxing the nose taste. Shen Congwen sigh: too little redneck! A trace of sadness like weeds as slowly breeding, yes ah, they where to go? "candidates to the geographical characteristics of the original author in the article were deleted, but the pattern and the rest of the text style of writing" is exactly the same.
The original author
Social problems should not be candidates to bear responsibility
Wang Kailing Department of Tengzhou, Shandong, Qufu Normal University in 1987 studying political, more than 100 His works are recorded "China Year prose", "China's annual best essay anthology.
Jiangsu candidates learned that his article was almost the original does not move onto the college entrance examination paper, he said, do not want to cancel the scores of the candidates, because it is a social issue and should not be borne by the candidates personal, he suspected Middle School teacher to find several Pham Van let them recite.
The reporter then interviewed several had participated in the entrance of the public. He graduated from Nanjing University, Mr. Wu recalled, during high school language results are really poor, but the number of physical and chemical performance is pretty good, general language does not hold back, when the language teacher of the school specifically for him and the class several language scores students prepare for the essay, let them back down, can be used for college entrance examination.
Examination Yuan
Are expert certification
Nanjing Jinling High School grade teacher of language subjects Yu Xu-Chu told reporters, this phenomenon is not the first time after many provinces there have been copied from the composition of the event.
Students now living face very narrow, for his writing to the color of the material too little, coupled with intense competition, the majority of students will be taken by way of short cuts, then recite some of the articles to meet college entrance essay. "Yu Xuchu said, now before the college entrance examination, many teachers will adapt to the needs of the exam, take the way of new stereotyped very little to let some of the usual reading, the accumulation of a few students to achieve better results, often ask students to recite some articles to deal with This out of utilitarian considerations of morals.
Related departments in charge of the Education and Examination Yuan in Jiangsu Province, said in an interview with the media, have heard there is a reflection of the alleged plagiarism, "We are also experts certified expert certification is not plagiarism." The hospital said that if it is determined for plagiarism will be informed of the results.
