In the film Association, said Zhejiang, the court trying to network judicial auction is illegal
- Details
- Category: Ningbo News
- Published: Tuesday, 07 August 2012 13:06
source 2012-8-7 11:46:10 The Beijing News
Zhejiang court system to try to network judicial auction on Taobao, lead to two different interpretations. Supporters argue that the traditional judicial auction commission is too high, the network auction, and the commission is zero, a way for the reform of judicial auction.
Auction industry practitioners, the film co-expressed opposition, that the law requires judicial auction must be conducted by the auction company, the Court of online auction behavior is to take the lead offense.
July 9, the first Taobao network judicial auction so far, its rise to the controversy continues.
August 3 and 6, the the Taobao judicial auction channel sub-two hung out four cars.
Following since July 9 for the first time the network judicial auction, the second network judicial Zhejiang Court held in Taobao auction, no auction companies to participate. Before and after the two auctions is Ningbo Beilun district court and Yinzhou District Court.
See the auction announcement, the Secretary-General of the auction industry associations in Zhejiang Province Wang Litian mood heavy. Nearly a month ago, Zhejiang Province, beat Association sent a letter to the Zhejiang Provincial High Court, and failed to resist the network judicial auction.
Judicial sale online
Been established since the 1998 judicial auction system and specifically commissioned the auction principle has been maintained so far. Now, Zhejiang local court to try to break this situation
At 10 o'clock on July 9th, Zhejiang Court auction held on Taobao for the first time.
Ningbo Beilun court auction "Baby" is a black the BMW WBAHN730 car, license plate number for the Zhejiang B8M189. After qualification Taobao users can participate in the auction.
Usually on the Internet "Amoy baby", the judicial auction need to pay deposit. The Beilun court auction BMW assess the price of 250,800 yuan, a starting price of 199,900 yuan, 50,000 yuan deposit. Taobao set the rate of increase for at least $ 1,000.
The online auction began 10 seconds after someone bids 200 900.
9 seconds after the fare increase of 2000 yuan.
8 seconds after the fare increase.
Less than one hour, this BMW car has been lifted to 323,900 yuan, higher than the starting price of 124,000 yuan.
At this point, Li Ying, director of the Beilun District Court Office has been glued to the computer before the price changes, and finally "relieved".
10:00 the evening of July 10, the auction end, after 53 asking price, the BMW car of the final sale price of 330,900 yuan. The number of buyers for the L1007, Jilin Liaoyuan people, four placards, win a $ 1,000.
On the 9th day, Yinzhou District Court of Beilun District Court at the same time a judicial auction on Taobao auction is a mini-van, license plate Zhejiang BX8105.
After 15 asking price, the ultimate mini-van was sold for 67,000 yuan. The car to assess the price of 58,650 yuan, a starting price of 50,000 yuan.
Li Ying, from the number of participants to the transaction prices have exceeded the expectations of the court.
Last year, Beilun District Court commissioned to auction 12 used cars, seven after an auction transaction, and an auction after the secondary, and the remaining four unsold.
Accordance with existing regulations, the court to sell the debtor's property must be auctioned. However, the court can not own the auction, must be entrusted to the auction company, auction companies for commissions.
Been established since the 1998 judicial auction system and specifically commissioned the auction principle has been maintained so far. Now, Zhejiang court to try to break this situation.
Beilun District, Ningbo City, Zhejiang Province, the courts and Yinzhou District Court, opened Taobao shop ", the judicial auction moved online. This is the two auction companies to participate in the auction.
After the end of the auction, the Zhejiang Provincial High Court, Ningbo Intermediate People's Court, the Court of Beilun, and Yinzhou the court together to open the forum, sum up the pros and cons. Li Ying said the pilot work was carried out under the unified arrangements of the Zhejiang Provincial High Court, Beilun District Court to become a pilot with the court of the advanced practice in forensic commissioned, but the hospital did not take the initiative to .
Try a judicial auction reform
February this year, the Supreme Court determined that suit the auction of the assets should be gradually bid through electronic trading platform and replaced by electronic competitive bidding hammer deal "
Zhejiang Provincial High Court with Taobao cooperation at the beginning of this year.
Since January 1 this year, "Supreme People's Court commissioned to assess the auction a number of provisions," began to require trial implementation entrusted to the auction separation. Judicial authorization of auction in Zhejiang Province, is no longer responsible for the executive department, but by the Forensic Department.
January 5, in the province's Court meeting, the president of the Zhejiang Provincial High Court Qi Qigong open, said, 2012 To the judicial auction onto Taobao or other network.
Qi Qi said, the past, have an interest driven, easy to corruption, since the sun of justice, we must open and transparent, and therefore use Taobao trading platform, or other network to the auction, the pilot reform of the judicial auction Internet bidding, and strive to auction "subject matter maximize the transaction price.
According to media reports, in the face of more than 100 Court of Zhejiang Province, Qi Qi said: "I am a question to test everyone, dean of grassroots courts with these auction company in the end there is no connection, to see the system propulsion. "
In February of this year, in the courts throughout the country to deepen the reform of the judicial auction meeting, Zhejiang High Court also expressed the above ideas.
Auction online to become fixed. In the above-mentioned meeting, the Supreme People's Court to determine the suit assets of the auction should be gradually through the electronic trading platform for auction hammer transactions by electronic competitive bidding to replace.
Subsequently, the Zhejiang High Court to try to Taobao as an auction platform, and sparked controversy in the local.
According to the Zhejiang local media reports, the Court fancy Taobao, because of its more mature technology and large customer base. The judge said that Taobao is headquartered in Hangzhou, and also to facilitate cooperation between the two sides.
Auctioneer Mr. Xu believes that the judicial auction on Taobao, not too serious. He speculated that the Court of the move may be on the show friendly image.
The auctioneer has long been engaged in a used car auction. The online auctions, BMW cars sold at high prices, he believes it is not surprising, on-site auction is not difficult to shoot the same price.
The film co-official letter of protest
Zhejiang Province, beat the Association submitted a report to the Zhejiang Provincial High Court, against put aside the auction company to auction on Taobao
Since June, Taobao launched a "judicial sale" channel, Wang Litian often visit Taobao, and collect questionable comments and reports of the network judicial auction, at the same time hang on the website of Zhejiang beat the Association. Wang Litian is the Secretary General of the auction industry associations in Zhejiang Province.
In the network before the judicial sale, the Zhejiang Provincial High Court did not communicate with the provincial film co. Zhejiang Province, beat the Association submitted a report to the Zhejiang Provincial High Court, opposed to set aside the auction company directly in the auction on Taobao. Wangli Tian said the High Court was no feedback, however, the Court of online auction thing not happened.
For the previous view that the judges of the Court of "connection" with the auction company, said Wang Litian, the court by the Yaohao determine the auction companies, auction company will not be the case implementation of the judge directly linked to self-established after the trial implementation entrusted auction separation mode, a province-wide, there is no judge and auction company in the judicial auction "playing tricks".
Wang Litian believe that the Court and the auction business cooperation rather than confrontation as "the enemy" relationship, not the normal work of judges and auction companies contact "demonized".
Supporters argue that the online auction commissions to zero, the transaction price is higher; in the shoot Association believes that the Court of online auctions illegal
The end of June, Wang Litian microblogging see the page of the judicial auction on Taobao, he reported to the Zhejiang Provincial Department of Commerce and the Chinese auction industry associations. Prior to the shooting of the network judicial auction, held in Zhejiang Province, beat Association president office meeting to discuss the decision to reflect the situation in a timely manner to all levels of authorities, and attention to ways and means, the same time, as always, assist the court to do a good job of Justice commissioned the auction work "take concrete actions to maintain a positive image of the industry."
On the basis of the discussion of ideas, the formation of a report entitled "High Court intends to implement judicial Taobao contact auction view" file. July 8, this document express letters of Zhejiang Provincial High Court.
"Not a substitute for the live auction
Zhejiang shot Association believes that Taobao audience and the bidder of the auction companies, a large number of potential customers do not know the auction
"Views" sent to the Zhejiang High Court on July 8, Zhejiang Province, beat the Association said, "to fully understand your hospital use of network technology to enhance efficiency in the first place of judicial auction, but said that such practices may bring many problems. concern. "
Zhejiang Province, beat the Association believes that the existing judicial authorization of auction management approach should continue, "Do not be denied. Wangli Tian said the High Court to bypass the auction company, is to completely obliterate the contribution of the auction industry.
Zhejiang Province, beat co-puzzled, even if the implementation of online auctions, no need to put aside the film co-find Taobao, because the the Zhejiang auction online "network in 2011 on the line.
Wang Litian introduction, the system can achieve on-site and network synchronization auction, there are many auction companies already in use, with good results.
Zhejiang Province, beat the Association believes that online auctions can not completely replace the live auction, Taobao customers many well-known, but the the Taobao audience and the bidder of the auction companies, a large number of potential customers do not know the auction, even many people will not use the network.
